Plumbing Zone - Professional Plumbers Forum banner

1 - 20 of 25 Posts

·
philosopher and statesmen
Joined
·
7,661 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
We get into an air b+b house and its having major troubles with the water heater ......

I talk them into a new Rheem Power vented unit.... The install goes great,,
then about 2 weeks pass and they start having intermittent hot water and the guests that stay there are all peeved about lukewarm water.....

So, Last friday afternoon I race up to the supply house and get the new control that goes on the power vent unit...... It some how clips onto the unit and a special tool will spring it off the body and all you have to do is snap the new one on and you are supposed to be good to go......

the problem with this is I noticed that the brass temperature sensor is not getting changed out when you do this and it is still imbedded in the water heater........ I realize that this is a major flaw just waiting to happen and I try to get the whole part but their are none available in town....

if it turns out to be the sensor that is bad you have to special order this
brass fitting with the sensor inside it....

Anyway , tonight they call and tell me the heater will not heat again....
so this means I get another Warranty service call out of Rheem and now someone has got to cough up a new brass body that goes into the heater....

I get the feeling I will be changing out the heater before they can get this oddball part to show up.....


I really dont understand why they would want to make something so difficult to where you could have just changed out the whole assembly in less than 5 minutes like most common water heaters are set up for....

but instead you have to stand on your head with a special tool and pry the box off the control body and hope that this half assed approach will actually repair the problem....when you gamble on the sensor inside the heater might also be the issue.....

very piss poor design, but my salesman is claiming that they all are going to this honeywell control box only being sent out...

thank you Rheem for making next week a challenge...

I am probably just going to claim the damn thing is leaking and swap it out and save myself a lot of greif and misery...


..







.














 

·
Registered
Joined
·
10,466 Posts
you just answered your own question..they are designed like that NOT to be fixed but easier to replace than try and chase parts and try to explain why they wont have hot water for a week, this one may be under warranty, but when the warranty on those type parts expire( I believe a while before the tank warranty expires), it wont be worth the cost and time of fixing than replacing..and you end up buying more heaters from them..
 

·
philosopher and statesmen
Joined
·
7,661 Posts
Discussion Starter · #3 ·
you just answered your own question..they are designed like that NOT to be fixed but easier to replace than try and chase parts and try to explain why they wont have hot water for a week, this one may be under warranty, but when the warranty on those type parts expire( I believe a while before the tank warranty expires), it wont be worth the cost and time of fixing than replacing..and you end up buying more heaters from them..
Well, that sucks if this is the case... this could be a lot of troubles after the warranty is out on the unit.... and I am being told that ALL of the brands are going to this design....

So, they would rather see me spend my day fooling around with my thumb up my ass attempting to make what they KNOW is probably a half-way repair instead of giving me a complete kit to be 100% sure the problem is resolved....:vs_mad:

I will be talking to the local Rheem rep real soon , to tell them what I think of their shi//y design ...



I had to raise hell and do about the same thing in 2004 when they increased the size of all their heaters by about 3 inches wider.. I got to talk to one of the head VPs at Rheem and explain why I stopped using their product.....eventually they shrunk the heater back down to a manageable size
..




 

·
Registered
Joined
·
10,466 Posts
Well, that sucks if this is the case... this could be a lot of troubles after the warranty is out on the unit.... and I am being told that ALL of the brands are going to this design....

So, they would rather see me spend my day fooling around with my thumb up my ass attempting to make what they KNOW is probably a half-way repair instead of giving me a complete kit to be 100% sure the problem is resolved....:vs_mad:

I will be talking to the local Rheem rep real soon , to tell them what I think of their shi//y design ...



I had to raise hell and do about the same thing in 2004 when they increased the size of all their heaters by about 3 inches wider.. I got to talk to one of the head VPs at Rheem and explain why I stopped using their product.....eventually they shrunk the heater back down to a manageable size
..




well I think more bad news will follow..with technology getting more complicated...and creaping into every part of life..
did you know skil chainsaws now have computer chips in them, so it took your ability to adjust fuel air mixtures, it has to be programed now...
so the same will happen to all products...
why you ask??? CONTROL....
just imagine all water heaters, boilers or any device having computers in them and hooked up to the internet and are monitored by???? who knows..and if you use too much energy..you get shut down...or what info they collect on your habits by your energy usage...
sound crazy?? just look around you the last few months and you would have said 7 or 8 months ago it would never be like what we are living NOW...
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
8,985 Posts
I’ll ask tomorrow, but I’m pretty sure when we’ve had a heater that goes bad unreasonably quick, that my supply house has forms to fill out and send in. We don’t get as much as we’d normally charge, but it’s something.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,829 Posts
I’ll ask tomorrow, but I’m pretty sure when we’ve had a heater that goes bad unreasonably quick, that my supply house has forms to fill out and send in. We don’t get as much as we’d normally charge, but it’s something.



Yeah it's no where near what a plumber would charge. That's why the warranty plumbers always have to find something wrong with an install in order to charge extra beyond the warranty.
 

·
philosopher and statesmen
Joined
·
7,661 Posts
Discussion Starter · #7 ·
I’ll ask tomorrow, but I’m pretty sure when we’ve had a heater that goes bad unreasonably quick, that my supply house has forms to fill out and send in. We don’t get as much as we’d normally charge, but it’s something.

I give them a bill for 150 to pick up the part and change it out.....
today I talked to our Rheem guy and basically I told him I was probably
just gonna change out the heater and warranty it out completely....

he was ok , fine with that...... or he said they would just throw me another 150 to change the shank out.....

of course this does not necessarily mean the heater will straighten out and fly right after doing this...

I prefer just changeing it
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
8,890 Posts
Yeah it's no where near what a plumber would charge. That's why the warranty plumbers always have to find something wrong with an install in order to charge extra beyond the warranty.
Ha one of the reps is always on my case saying I'll put you on my list for water heater repair or a replacement. Then I asked how much it paid, I laughed at him outright. The repair paid less than my service call without adding my 1hr minimum, it just covered gas and I'd be working for free .

The replacement was about (after taxes) 80$. so basically they are idiots. No one is buying their stuff anyways.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,829 Posts
Ha one of the reps is always on my case saying I'll put you on my list for water heater repair or a replacement. Then I asked how much it paid, I laughed at him outright. The repair paid less than my service call without adding my 1hr minimum, it just covered gas and I'd be working for free .

The replacement was about (after taxes) 80$. so basically they are idiots. No one is buying their stuff anyways.
I've dealt with the warranty plumbers in my area a few times and if he can find ANYTHING wrong with the install the warranty work can not be done until the problems are repaired and he hits you with a 300 dollar show up charge. That's how they make their money on warranty work in commercial .
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,829 Posts
Mark, can you post any pictures or a video next time?

Thanks. I have not run into this...............yet.



I have some pictures of a AO Smith that has a similar damn sensor buried in the tank but it's a commercial heater and I had to wait a week to get this damn sensor to get the heater working on a brand new project. It's the BTH high efficiency model, I will see if I can find the pics. You have to drain over half the tank down just to change the sensor.
 

·
philosopher and statesmen
Joined
·
7,661 Posts
Discussion Starter · #13 ·
I'd think about changing more than the heater, like changing brands.
They claim that even bradford white is using the very same honeywell valve...with no brass insert into the heater....

If it gives me any more issues, I will switch it out to a bradford and just warranty out the heater later in the year....
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,023 Posts
I'd think about changing more than the heater, like changing brands.
They claim that even bradford white is using the very same honeywell valve...with no brass insert into the heater....

If it gives me any more issues, I will switch it out to a bradford and just warranty out the heater later in the year....
I install Bradford. I’ve yet to see the chinsey valve on them.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,269 Posts
We get into an air b+b house and its having major troubles with the water heater ......

I talk them into a new Rheem Power vented unit.... The install goes great,,
then about 2 weeks pass and they start having intermittent hot water and the guests that stay there are all peeved about lukewarm water.....

So, Last friday afternoon I race up to the supply house and get the new control that goes on the power vent unit...... It some how clips onto the unit and a special tool will spring it off the body and all you have to do is snap the new one on and you are supposed to be good to go......

the problem with this is I noticed that the brass temperature sensor is not getting changed out when you do this and it is still imbedded in the water heater........ I realize that this is a major flaw just waiting to happen and I try to get the whole part but their are none available in town....

if it turns out to be the sensor that is bad you have to special order this
brass fitting with the sensor inside it....

Anyway , tonight they call and tell me the heater will not heat again....
so this means I get another Warranty service call out of Rheem and now someone has got to cough up a new brass body that goes into the heater....

I get the feeling I will be changing out the heater before they can get this oddball part to show up.....


I really dont understand why they would want to make something so difficult to where you could have just changed out the whole assembly in less than 5 minutes like most common water heaters are set up for....

but instead you have to stand on your head with a special tool and pry the box off the control body and hope that this half assed approach will actually repair the problem....when you gamble on the sensor inside the heater might also be the issue.....

very piss poor design, but my salesman is claiming that they all are going to this honeywell control box only being sent out...

thank you Rheem for making next week a challenge...

I am probably just going to claim the damn thing is leaking and swap it out and save myself a lot of greif and misery...









.
The solution is simple and you already know what to do,take your 440 channel locks and beat the crap out of the pieces,then it will come into compliance and work correctly:biggrin::biggrin::biggrin:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
10,466 Posts
The solution is simple and you already know what to do,take your 440 channel locks and beat the crap out of the pieces,then it will come into compliance and work correctly:biggrin::biggrin::biggrin:
2 foot rigid pipe wrench is easier on the hands while beating controls into submission to work...
 

·
philosopher and statesmen
Joined
·
7,661 Posts
Discussion Starter · #18 ·
2 foot rigid pipe wrench is easier on the hands while beating controls into submission to work...
I took the heater out last week on a Sat afternoon , got tired of messing with it and people were staying at this Air B+b place.....

its Rheems problem now
 

·
philosopher and statesmen
Joined
·
7,661 Posts
Discussion Starter · #20 ·
Next time please post a video or photos of the offending parts.



actually I tore out an 8 year old rheem tankless water heater that was venting out the side of the house in a triple wall vent system ...Only went about a foot up and 2 foot out the side of the home.... It turned out that the heater was scaling up and clogging up all the hot water lines in the home.... and they did not want to invest in a water softener or attempt to de-lime the unit.... so out it went

I threw in this power vent unit and it gave me fits every time someone came to stay at the home on friday and satrudays......



after changing out the control only , and also the pressure switch, and I could not get the shank with the heat sensor which screwed into the tank, I totally lost my cool and just tore it out and installed a standard rheem water heater and it goes out the side of the house through the triple wall vent system....

it is venting perfectly and it is what I should have installed in the first place...
 
1 - 20 of 25 Posts
Top